Honest reviews and practical swaps for healthier everyday living
Sleep and Recovery

Coop Pillow Review: Bought in 2018, Bought Again in 2023, and I Still Prefer Down

By Alex Anderson Updated October 2026 8 min read No sponsors. Paid links are labeled.

In This Article

There are two orders for this pillow in my Amazon history. One in 2018, one in 2023. My wife found it. I rolled with it, and the second one was hers.

It is a really good pillow. I have been using one for at least a year and I call it great. I also still prefer down, and down is expensive, so you can guess how this review goes.

Below: what shows up in the box, what the bag of extra stuffing is for, what it should cost you, and what the two certifications on the listing cover. Then the part where foam loses to down.

What comes in the box

A pillow and a bag.

The pillow is a zippered case stuffed with what Coop calls Oomph fill. The Amazon listing gives the recipe: 76 percent shredded memory foam and 24 percent polyester gel fiber. The foam is torn into small pieces, so it shifts under your head the way a stuffed pillow does. A solid foam block would not.

The bag is more of the same fill. They give you extra stuffing to add if you need it, and you can pull some out if you do not. My wife added some of it to hers. I left mine as it came, and it is perfect.

Coop’s own site lists the outer cover as 60 percent polyester and 40 percent viscose rayon made from bamboo, over a polyester liner. The queen is 19 by 29 inches. The king is 19 by 35.

Why the extra fill matters

Most pillows are one height. Somebody at the factory picked it, and you live with it.

The research points at height too. A 2021 review in Clinical Biomechanics pulled together 35 pillow trials and looked at neck alignment in side sleepers. Rubber against feather made no clear difference there. The authors wrote that alignment “may be significantly impacted by the shape and height of the pillow”.1

The usual rule of thumb fits. Side sleepers have a shoulder to clear and tend to want more loft, back sleepers less, stomach sleepers hardly any. Coop’s listing puts it this way: take fill out for a softer, lower pillow and put fill in for a firmer, taller one.

The listing also warns that foam feels firmer in a cold room, so a pillow that was right in July can feel stiff in January. If it packs flat over time, Coop’s site says ten minutes in the dryer brings it back.

Keep the spare fill. The sleeve that came with mine is still in my closet in case I changed my mind. I did not, but you cannot add what you threw away.

Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow (Queen)

Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow with its box and the bag of extra fill

4.5 stars across more than 64,000 Amazon ratings. The king is the same pillow six inches wider and was $79.20 the same day.

Purchase signal: Repeat buy. Ordered in 2018, ordered again in 2023.

Price: $71.20 for the queen against a list price of $89.00, checked October 7, 2026.

Check price on Amazon

The price, honestly

I paid under fifty dollars for mine. The queen lists at $89.00 now and was selling for $71.20 the day I wrote this.

It might not be worth ninety dollars. I like the pillow a lot and I would still say that. So here is how not to pay ninety.

Nobody should pay list. $71.20 is the price it keeps coming back to. Slickdeals logged it at $71.20 in February 2026, PopSci had it at $71.20 for Prime Day in June, and it was $71.20 again on October 7. A 20 percent sale is the normal state of things, so treat $71.20 as the real price and $89 as the sticker.

It has gone lower. Amazon had the queen at $47.99 in June 2021 and $57.59 on Prime Day 2022, both logged on Slickdeals. More recently Tom’s Guide reported 25 percent off for Black Friday, which put the queen at $63.75. If Black Friday week is close, wait for it.

And there is a cheaper way into the same idea from the same company. Coop sells a down alternative pillow, the Essence, in a set of two. It was $44.49 for the pair when I checked, against an $89.00 list price. It is polyester fill made to feel like down, with the same zip open cover and a bag of extra fill. I have not tested it and I am going on the listing, which also shows a lower rating: 4.0 stars against 4.5.

Coop Home Goods Essence Down Alternative Pillow, Set of 2 (Queen)

Two Coop Essence down alternative pillows with the storage bag and a bag of extra fill

Two adjustable pillows for less than one Original. OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified, 4.0 stars from about 1,100 ratings.

Picked for: The price, the adjustable fill and the down style feel. I have not tested it.

Price: $44.49 for the set of two on October 7, 2026, list $89.00.

Check price on Amazon

What the labels on the listing mean

Two certifications are printed on the listing, and both are narrower than they sound.

CertiPUR-US is about the foam. A certified foam has been tested for its content and for what it gives off, and the program bars a list of things, including certain flame retardants, formaldehyde and heavy metals.

GREENGUARD Gold is about the finished product. It is an emissions standard run by UL, and it caps how much volatile chemistry a product may release into indoor air.

I would want both on something a face rests on all night. The fill is still polyurethane foam and polyester. If you want natural fill more than you want adjustability, look at wool or latex.

Where down still wins for me

I still prefer down, and it is expensive. The ones I mean are old school down pillows from ages ago, and they were great. That is also why there is no link to one here.

The Coop has two things over them in my book. It is not an animal product, which to me means no feather allergens to think about. And it is washable.

Before you spend down money, read one trial. An Australian trial had side sleepers try five pillows for a week each: polyester, regular foam, contoured foam, feather and latex. The feather pillow did worst. It produced the most stiff necks and headaches on waking, and more people quit that week than any other. Latex did best.2

Feather is not down, and the trial did not test a down pillow. A foam pillow is not allergy proof either, since dust mites will move into any pillow, which is one more reason the washable part matters. I take the trial as a warning anyway. A soft pillow is not automatically a supportive one, and what I like may not suit your neck.

The same trial found the contoured foam pillow did no better than the plain foam one. So I would not pay extra for a sculpted shape. I would pay for being able to change the height.

Washing it and the return window

Washable is on my list of reasons, and Coop’s site backs it up: the pillow and the outer cover are both machine washable. The cover zips off, which is the piece worth washing often.

The site also advertises a 100 night trial and a five year warranty. Neither one is something the order record lets me vouch for. If you are buying through Amazon and counting on the trial, check with Coop that an Amazon order is covered before the return window on the order closes.

Who should skip it

Skip it if you want natural fill. This is foam and polyester.

Skip it if you like a pillow that springs back at you. Shredded memory foam sinks and stays put, and latex is the bouncy one.

And skip it if you do not want a project. Coop’s whole pitch is that you tune the fill yourself, which can mean adding and removing until it feels right. Mine needed nothing. My wife added some to hers. If you want to open a box and be done, buy a fixed pillow you have already tried in a store.

Quick questions

Is the Coop pillow worth it?
At what I paid, under fifty dollars, yes. A second one went on the order history five years after the first. At $89 I am less sure, which is why there is a whole section above on not paying that.

Can you make it softer?
Yes. Per the listing, taking fill out makes it softer. The spare bag is for going the other way, which is what my wife did.

Does it help with neck pain?
I cannot promise that. The review above found that pillow height affects how the neck sits, and this pillow lets you change the height. The evidence stops there.

Queen or king?
Match your pillowcases. The fill is the same and the king is six inches wider.

Is it better than a down pillow?
For feel, I still like down more. This one is washable, adjustable and not made from an animal, and down is expensive.

The bottom line

Two orders five years apart, the second for my wife, at least a year of use, and I call it a great pillow. The spare fill is why I would pick it over a fixed foam pillow: you get to set the height.

If you can afford down and already know you like it, buy down. Otherwise this is where I would start, on sale.

References

The pillow research cited above was opened on PubMed on October 7, 2026.

  1. Chun-Yiu JP, Man-Ha ST, Chak-Lun AF. The effects of pillow designs on neck pain, waking symptoms, neck disability, sleep quality and spinal alignment in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Biomech (Bristol). 2021 May;85:105353. PubMed
  2. Gordon SJ, Grimmer-Somers KA, Trott PH. Pillow use: the behavior of cervical stiffness, headache and scapular/arm pain. J Pain Res. 2010 Aug 11;3:137-45. PubMed
Affiliate disclosure: Links to Amazon are affiliate links.
I earn a small commission if you purchase through these links, at no
additional cost to you. I only recommend products I’ve personally used or
researched thoroughly. This helps support the work behind Better Living
Every Day.
Alex Anderson

About Alex Anderson

I got tired of reading ingredient labels and finding seed oils, BPA, and endocrine disruptors in everything I brought into my home. So I started this site to share what I actually buy, cook with, clean with, and use day to day. Most of those products link out to Amazon. Using those links costs you nothing (Amazon sometimes has a coupon clipped on the product page), and the small commission helps cover the hosting bill. No sponsors, no brand deals. Just real products I keep in my own kitchen, laundry room, bathroom, and pantry. Not all of it comes from Amazon, though. Grass-fed beef, pasture-raised chicken and eggs, grass-fed butter and sourdough I buy at the farmers market when I can, because it beats the store and it supports my community.

One good swap, every week

No spam, no sponsors, no 40-email funnels. Just the swaps we actually made and whether they stuck.

Double opt-in. Unsubscribe anytime, we never share your address.