Just here for the picks? Jump to the 5 fats I cook with →
In This Article
A few years back the seed-oil fight was everywhere and I got sick of it. So I stopped arguing and just looked at what was actually in my pan. Didn’t love the answer. These are the five fats I cook with instead now, from the hottest searing oil down to a light everyday spray.
Did it change my life? Nope. But each one earned its spot by the stove, and I grab them now on autopilot.
Beef tallow, the comeback fat
Tallow is beef fat, rendered down. It’s how a lot of cooking got done before the oil aisle took over. Two things sold me. It takes real heat without smoking and scorching the way thin oils do, and it makes roast potatoes taste the way you always hoped they would. I’ve bought the Wagyu tub twice.
Hard as a candle in the jar, liquid the second it hits a hot pan. And no, it doesn’t make your eggs taste like a burger. It just makes them better.
Duck fat, the one people sleep on
Duck fat is the sleeper here, and honestly it’s what got me into this in the first place. Never had duck fat fries? Go fix that. Cut potatoes, coat them in melted duck fat, roast them hot. Crackly outside, fluffy middle. Nothing else quite nails it.
And it’s not just potatoes. It crisps up sprouts and roasts vegetables just as happily. A little does a lot, and my jar sits in the fridge for months.
Algae oil, the highest smoke point
This is the newest one in my rotation and the surprise of the group. Algae oil sounds like a science project, but it’s just a neutral oil pressed from algae, and it shrugs off more heat than anything else here, around 535 degrees. Nothing else I keep comes close.
So it’s become my steak oil. When I want a hard sear and a pan hot enough to worry the smoke alarm, this is what goes in, and it doesn’t add any taste of its own. Tallow and duck fat I keep for flavor. This one I keep for when I just need the heat.
Avocado oil, the everyday workhorse
Avocado oil is the boring default for a normal night. It takes real heat and tastes like almost nothing, so it never fights the food. I buy the spray so I quit drowning my vegetables in oil. Same stuff, less mess.
Coconut oil, the one I’ve bought under every brand name
I’ve lost count of how many brands of coconut oil I’ve gone through. It’s my baking fat, my lower-heat fat, and half the jar somehow ends up on my hands as a moisturizer. Want the coconut smell? Extra-virgin. Don’t? Refined is basically flavorless.
Smoke points at a glance
Smoke point is just the temperature where an oil starts to break down and smoke. Higher means it handles hotter cooking. These are ballpark numbers, since they shift a little with refinement and brand.
| Oil | Smoke point | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Algae oil | ~535°F | The hottest work: searing steak, stir-fry, deep frying |
| Avocado oil | ~500°F | Everyday high-heat cooking and roasting |
| Beef tallow | ~400°F | Searing, roasting, fries |
| Duck fat | ~375°F | Roasting potatoes and vegetables, frying |
| Coconut oil (virgin) | ~350°F | Medium heat and baking |
The picks I keep buying
South Chicago Packing Wagyu Beef Tallow (the high-heat fat)
The fat that makes roast potatoes taste the way you always hoped they would. I’ve rebought this tub twice.
Size: 42 oz tub
My take: Solid in the jar, liquid the moment it hits the pan. It doesn’t taste beefy, it just makes food better.
Fatworks Duck Fat (for duck fat fries)
The move for duck fat fries and anything else you want crackly. Fatworks is the brand I trust for rendered fats.
Size: 7.5 oz jar
My take: A little goes a long way, and the jar keeps for months in the fridge. Worth it for the fries alone.
Algae Cooking Club Algae Oil (highest smoke point, ~535°F)
My highest smoke point by a mile, around 535°F. This is the one I reach for to sear a steak or run a pan screaming hot without smoking out the kitchen.
Size: 16 fl oz
My take: Totally neutral, so it stays out of the way of the food. The high-heat pick when you don’t want the flavor of tallow or duck fat.
Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Spray (the everyday workhorse)
My medium-to-high-heat default for a normal night. Neutral taste, high smoke point, and the spray keeps me from overpouring.
Size: 13.5 oz spray
My take: Same clean avocado oil as the bottle, just less mess on a sheet pan of vegetables.
Nutiva Organic Virgin Coconut Oil (baking & lower heat)
My baking and lower-heat fat, and half the jar ends up on my hands because it doubles as a decent moisturizer. I’ve bought it across brands for years.
Size: 15 fl oz
My take: Extra-virgin has a light coconut scent. Want it neutral? Get the refined version instead.
Quick questions
So what’s actually wrong with seed oils?
Depends who you ask, and both camps oversell it. My reason was dumber than the internet’s: I wanted fewer heavily processed fats and something that wouldn’t break down over high heat. If you’re happy with canola, use canola.
Do I need all five?
Nope. If you only grab one, make it tallow or duck fat for flavor, or algae oil if you sear a lot of steak. Avocado oil is the everyday workhorse, and coconut oil is more of a baking thing.
Isn’t duck fat unhealthy?
It’s a traditional cooking fat, same family as tallow and lard. I treat it like any rich fat: fantastic in moderation, not something I deep-fry a vat of every day.
This is what I keep in my own kitchen, not nutrition advice. Fats are calorie dense, and swapping oils doesn’t cancel out the rest of what’s on the plate.